PDA

View Full Version : Schrade XT1B


Bad_Omen
03-22-2007, 11:57 PM
Just got me a brand spanking new knife and I thought I'd share my impressions of it with you, A review of sorts.

My trusty (very) old K-bar has spent the last year or so in storage in my garage with a good portion of my worldly goods while I try and turn the barn we bought in France into a habitable family home. Unfortunately the box it was in got damp and caused a fair amount of rust. Not terrible amounts but enough. For instance the press-studs on the sheath were eaten away. Anyway, I spent some time cleaning the knife up and repairing the sheath and all in all it's looking pretty good. However there’s some pitting on the blade. Not vast amounts but enough to mean I can't get a perfect edge without taking the edge way back. I as I've had this knife for more years than I care to count (15+) I figured it was time to retire the old girl and invest in a pup to take her place.

So the search for a new survival/camp knife began in earnest. The criteria were fairly simple. Not too big, not too small, comfortable to use and it had to have a serrated edge. Oh year and the price had to be right, I'm not in a position to spend a couple of hundred Euros on a new knife at the moment. The Mrs would use it on various parts of my anatomy that I'm rather attached to before I'd get to give it it's first sharpen.

So, with all that in mind I set about trying to find the perfect knife. There are no real camping shops round here so my choice was fairly limited. Nothing fitting the bill could be found. So I started looking on-line. Not ideal as there are certain things I feel a man should hold before he buys and a knife's one of them. During my search I must have looked a hundreds of knives but the one that kept catching my eye was the Schrade XT1B, part of their X-Timer range. I looked into them and although the company has gone belly up (never a good sign) the knife ticked all the right boxes.

Well I decided to take the risk and bought one. It certainly didn’t break the bank at $37.74 inc. shipping all the way from the good old USofA to France. Shipping took a little longer than expected but I think that’s the fault of French customs rather than the shop. I’d ordered it on Sunday 04 March, 2007 and it arrived this morning, Friday 23 March 2007, so about 20 days. Not bad in the scheme of things. I have to admit to getting a bit worried by the delay and sending a few mails to the shop asking incessant questions about the shipping. All mails were answered and they gave all the help they could, so full credit to them. I’d happily recommend them to anyone looking for a knife but I’m not sure of the rules because I guess it’s kind of advertising another website. If Oliver says its ok I’ll share it with you.

On to the knife itself. It arrived well packed from the shop and upon ripping the box open like a kid at Christmas I was presented with the box proper. Nothing too exciting there and I’m sure you’re not that interested in Schrade’s packaging. Inside was the knife in it’s sheath and some very rudimentary instructions. Here are some pictures I nabbed off the net so you can see what we’re talking about.

Bad_Omen
03-22-2007, 11:58 PM
http://www.thenashgang.com/images/shrade/SchradeXTB1-01.jpg
http://www.thenashgang.com/images/shrade/SchradeXTB1-02.jpg
http://www.thenashgang.com/images/shrade/SchradeXTB1-04.jpg
http://www.thenashgang.com/images/shrade/SchradeXTB1-05.jpg
http://www.thenashgang.com/images/shrade/SchradeXTB1-06.jpg

Bad_Omen
03-22-2007, 11:59 PM
First impressions were good; it’s a well sized, well balanced, solid knife that feels good in the hand. The handle is comfy to grip both over and underhand and being made of rubber gives plenty of grip. Onto the blade, now unfortunately this is a Schrade that was made in china. You can still find X-timers that were made in the USA but I believe they’re getting a bit like rocking horse poo. Still never mind, there’s talk that the steel used on the Chinese models aren’t as good as the US ones but I guess only time will tell. The edge felt good straight out of the box, good but not perfect. I ran it down my arm and managed to get a fair few hairs off which is my standard test for an edge. Once that proved satisfactory a few pieces of newspaper were sacrificed and ritually slaughtered in the interests of this article. Like I said, good but not perfect, the edge was a little ragged for my liking. Nothing a few moments with the strop couldn’t sort out, so all in all a very good edge straight outa the box. The serrated edge is very good, nice sized serrations and plenty sharp enough. I’ll be giving it a proper workout over the weekend so I’ll post an update afterwards.

The one thing that I’m not convinced about is the sheath. Don’t get me wrong, it’s nice enough and at first glance looks well made. My problem is, is it fit for purpose? I’m just not sure it’ll stand up to much punishment. Especially once that serrated edge gets to work on it. You can feel it drag as you draw. We’ll see in the fullness of time. The other slight issue with the sheath for me is how far up it wraps round the handle. I’ve never used this style of sheath before so maybe it’ll just take some getting used to. I like to unsnap the ‘safety’ and wrap my whole hand around the handle, get a proper, safe and secure grip then yank it out. Having so little of the handle exposed means I can only grip with a couple of fingers till the handle clears the sheath, not sure a like that.

So there you have it. The Schrade XT1B, on first impressions a good sized, solid survival knife that won’t break the bank. I’ll be giving it a shake down over the weekend so I’ll fill you in on how well it performs in the field.

Bad_Omen
03-23-2007, 03:33 AM
Oliver has told me it's ok to post a link to the shop I bought this from. So here you go.

www.wildeals.com

333
03-23-2007, 09:50 AM
peace,

Excellent looking piece and article. I personally have an old "buck" knife from father gotta be 50 plus years old. It isn't much to look at, 99. 5% rust free, hold a nice edge, and opens them four legged creatures like a scalpel. The sheath has about had it, maybe one of these days I' ll locate a comparable new one.

Congrats,

Thanks,

Peace

Bad_Omen
03-27-2007, 12:00 AM
Well now despite some (loads) of adverse weather over the weekend my new toy did get some use. Nothing exciting just a general test of it's usability whilst walking the dog. Down side of this is that I was unable to test it on any game so it's not exactly a conclusive test.

The good news is it works fine. For the kind of cutting tasks encountered in and around camp it worked like a charm. Small to medium sized branches present no obstacle and thanks to the size and weight of the blade chopping at larger poles wasn't a chore. Despite the size it's a very controllable knife so more delicate tasks where manageable.

I was surprised by how well the serrated edge worked. It did a very good job without much clogging or binding which is unusual on a knife. My only criticism would be that it's a bit short, but then it's a knife first and a saw second.

I used it with and without gloves and found no comfort, control or grip problems with the handle. I even used it wet and the rubber gripped like the proverbial to a blanket.

I had a good look at *it when I got home and was pleased to find that the edge was fine, no nicking or undue dulling after a fair amount of chopping and hacking tasks. Looks like it should stand up to the usual tasks just fine. The other nice surprise was the black finish was untouched. Yes it's a tool first and foremost, but where's it written that tools can't look good. *:D

I'm still not overly enamoured with the sheath but having said that I didn't drop it all weekend so maybe it's something I'll get used to.

As far as I'm concerned it's a good solid tool that doesn't break the bank and is probably worth a look if you're in the market for a new knife

Old_John
04-12-2007, 12:59 AM
Well It's sad, about losing the use of the K-Bar.
They are good solid knives. They are a little big, for fine work.
Good, on ya, getting the Schrade. They use to make a good solid product, too. I'm not sure, how the new ones from China are though.

I still carry an old Marble, with about a 4" blade.
My DoD(Dear Old Dad), gave it to me on my 12th birthday.
Makes it about 55 years old, hunnh.
Still got a nice little blade. I can't count the number of rabbits & squirrels that Marble has cleaned.
I don't hunt much any more. I've got kinda old & lazy.
But, I still go for a walk with the 12 ga., on occasaion.
Enjoy your new Blade.