I think I’ve mentioned in the past the pitfalls of having a gun in New York State, and people getting arrested for illegal possession when they checked in at an airport counter and didn’t have NY state issued paper for it.  This story comes from my friend John, a retired cop in California:


Some years back my wife and I flew to NYC to be the last guests of the WALDORF—ASTORIA before the wrecking ball turned it into Tapioca.

While packing, I noticed some issues with my Compact .45 and immediately sent it out for repair. The only other suitable firearm I owned was my old Detective Special—that I owned since the early 1980’s. (And when I mean suitable: I had fresh ammo and a suitable holster.)

Thankfully, we encountered no issues while in NYC, and we headed to JFK to fly home. At the ticket counter I declared an unloaded firearm in my luggage. And as you well know, that is proper and legal.

Ticket agent asks for a NYS Pistol Permit, which I don’t have. “So you’re law enforcement?” I told him I’m retired and authorized in all 50-states.

“Wait here—the police have been notified!”

A few minutes later, a pair of young Port Authority cops arrive. I show my retired ID—which passes muster. Then they want to examine the gun.

Bottom line: Those two young cops did not know how to open the cylinder on a Colt revolver.

33 COMMENTS

  1. Seems like firearms training needs to add a little extra to the course. Those Detective Specials are a reliable sidearm. Some of these new recruits need to know that there are good firearms between a muzzleloader and a Glock…

    • Or drive a stick shift. Or since it is NYC, drive at all. I knew a guy from there that flew jets in combat before he learned to drive.

  2. I regularly shoot a ‘qual’ with my .38 Agent at Staccato Ranch. You’d think I should wear overalls and a straw hat for some of the looks I get from the youngsters.
    Meh, ‘fuds’ are what studs grow into – if they’re lucky.

    • Back when it was still Front Sight, I did a class with an SP101. They weren’t so stuffy in those days. There was a guy who was a triple amputee and the remaining arm was damaged running a revolver. Got hit by something big in Vietnam. Everyone cheered when he qualified. Qual was much harder than POST. Guy had a wonderful, sunny attitude. I gave a thought to the medic who got him back.

  3. A recent video shows officers relieving a crazy woman of a small derringer as they placed her under arrest. His body cam showed one officer farting around with the gun and flagging everybody for several minutes while repeatedly saying “I don’t know how to open this thing.” I kept waiting for a bang.

  4. The irony here being the fact that for many, many years the NYPD issued Colt Detective Specials as a choice for an officer’s off duty gun.

  5. Sort of know the feeling. Went into Old Tucson Studios, in 1880 attire, with a holstered pistol. “Wait here for security to check your weapon.” I don’t believe the youngster had ever seen a cap and ball revolver in his life. (1860 Army Colt – modern replica.) I was let in.

  6. I wonder what would happen if every high schooler were required to know how to clear a revolver, a semi, a shotgun, & a long rifle. It’s only a hunch, but I suspect there would be great value in eliminating the romanticism of the unknown and replacing it with responsible knowledge.

    • My wife shot all three of her MN carry-permit qualifications with her carry gun, an SP101, .357, with a 2″ barrel. She was shooting her standard carry ammo of .38+P with 125-grain JHP’s.

      And she did ’em all in double-action.

  7. Several years ago, I worked at a large gun store which bought & sold used firearms as well as new ones. One of the perks we firearms salesmen had was that we got the first look at all the used firearms that we purchased from customers as we acquired them & we were allowed to claim whichever ones we wanted to purchase for ourselves by tagging them with our names & our intent to purchase them when we put them back in the gun vault. Our volume of business was large enough that we acquired some used guns virtually every day.

    I was the “old guy” there as most of my coworkers were in their 20’s & 30’s & as such they had no interest whatsoever in revolvers or any old semi-autos at all. They were only interested in tactical rifles, shotguns, & handguns (primarily 1911’s). This meant that I had my choice of whichever “old guns” I wanted & as they noticed my interest in them, they would let me know whenever we acquired something they thought I might like. The result was that while I was employed there, I bought myself several used Colt revolvers including Detective Specials, Cobras, Agents, Diamondbacks, a 1972 Python in near mint condition, & a Single Action Army. I also bought several “old” Smith & Wesson revolvers, Winchester lever actions, & various semi-autos too numerous to mention. The fact that they were “used” guns & that I could also use my employee discount to buy them meant that I almost always got them for less than half of what they were really worth. I still have all of them & I enjoy shooting them whenever I can. I even carry some of them concealed from time to time for fun. My preference is for guns in perfect mechanical condition with a little bit of holster wear on the finish so I don’t have to keep them looking perfect. I’m very grateful to have been able to buy so many guns that I wanted, but couldn’t afford to buy when I was young & they were new.

  8. That’s almost as bad as the young clerks at McDonald’s refusing a silver dollar or a $2.00 bill which they believe to be counterfeit.

  9. I’ve got a vague memory of a video (early in car camera?) of a Texas highway patrol officer who stopped the then women’s IPSC champ and the-to most of those watching the video later-hysterically funny interaction while he handled her HK P7 squeeze cocker. He’d no clue and didn’t want to listen to her. OK, LLEAs can’t familiarize the troops with all the various systems, but they should at least familiarize with commonly used systems.

    I think the issue for individuals may be a lack of the educational system not relating both application what’s being taught to the real world AND what they’re not teaching. Like logic.

    McDs-at some, the cash registers had pictures of the menu items on the keys instead of numbers. The local one has gone to self order kiosks and apparently only takes credit cards.

  10. In the second or third Concealed Handgun class I taught a student wanted to know if he could take the qualification with his single-action revolver. There wasn’t a rule against it, so we let him. He shot faster than the semiautos and reloaded faster than the double-action wheelgun shooters. Ourt of 50 rounds at three, seven, and 15 yards he had two “flyers” in the 9-ring. Turns out he was a cowboy. (The real deal.) He had been carrying that gun for 30 years.
    After class he told me some of his friends suggested he get a modern gun to carry and wanted my opinion. Which was, “Ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

    • Wow! I can understand shooting a single-action revolver fairly quickly. Being right-handed, I hold my revolvers with my right hand, and work the hammers with my left thumb. But reloading a single-action faster than a swing-out cylinder double-action? Were the wheelgun shooters loading single rounds, or were they using speed loaders and/or speed strips? Either way, that cowboy did some crazy good shooting.

      • They were loading single rounds. In the Texas practical the number of cartridges loaded varies between stages and depends on whether I have a five-shot handgun on the line, so pistol shooters were also loading magazines. The other revolver shooters weren’t as familiar with their sidearms as the cowboy was. One of them were loading “backwards,” holding the revolver in his shooting hand, and loading with his off-hand. (Not something I wanted to try to correct just before he took a test.)

  11. we are living in the future!
    and if you thought that made you feel like a dinosaur:

    https://youtu.be/-9oggZM7PPU?si=mN6uQaLCU6_XwqGG

    25 Skills That Will Be Useless In 10 Years

    0:30 – Memorizing Phone Numbers
    1:17 – Reading a Physical Map
    2:21 – Cursive Handwriting
    3:16 – Manual Cash Handling and Making Change
    4:20 – Parallel Parking
    5:12 – Filing Taxes Manually
    6:10 – Basic Photo Editing
    6:57 – Driving a Manual Transmission
    7:42 – Speed Typing
    8:27 – Organizing Digital Files and Photos
    9:22 – Setting Up Cable TV
    10:12 – Data Entry
    11:02 – Traditional Library Research
    12:02 – Foreign Language Basics for Travel
    12:55 – Manual Bookkeeping
    13:43 – Basic Coding
    14:37 – Traditional Marketing Skills
    15:33 – Shorthand Writing
    16:33 – Manual Inventory Management
    17:21 – Driving a Car
    18:00 – Maintaining a Home Network
    18:48 – Troubleshooting Basic Software Bugs
    19:28 – Proofreading and Grammar Checking
    20:22 – Translating Documents
    21:21- Rote Memorization

    njk

    • Some of the listed skills are worthless now. But on many, you are mistaken. I know which ones will always be valuable. Do you?

    • As long as the power stays on. AI is a power hog. Trump wisely wants the server farms to produce their own electricity, but the USA has so many environmental regulations I bet it will take a long time to fully implement AI. Also, when we attacked Iran, I expected them to take out our power grid by hacking into it.

      I really don’t know what I’m typing about, but if someone knows more about this subject, I would like to read it.

      So, will the future be like the Jetsons, or like Mad Max? Or, will the future be similar to the present?

  12. 20 years ago a nearby department made for their own use a training video showing how to operate – and clear – a variety of firearms, including black powder.

    I said they should have marketed it. I’ve yet to see anything like it for sale.

  13. When I attended the police academy in 1978 I qualified with a S&W #65 (six-shot service revolver). The drill was a 10 shot exercise for time. Load 5-rounds, shoot at the target, dump your brass, reload , shoot 5-more rounds, dump brass. (Game over). Using speedloaders, I could shoot all 10 rounds and finish the drill faster (and with accuracy) than my classmates with 9-mm/.45 semi-automatics finished their first five rounds.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here