In mid-October an apparently mentally ill sixteen-year-old entered an elementary school in Bend, Oregon and murdered three children and an adult and wounded two more victims. His murder spree was cut short when a thirty-something father of two young students there happened to be passing by, saw the gunman approaching the school, and stopped his vehicle and ran in with a .40 caliber pistol. He chased down the gunman and ultimately killed him. The mass murderer still had 44 live shotgun shells to feed the 12 gauge pump gun his mother had purchased for him.
The first mainstream news broadcast I saw on the incident was on ABC Morning News, and when they referred to the young dad as an “armed hero” my first thought was “Damn, maybe there’s hope for mainstream news after all.”
Note the solid points in favor of armed citizens by the pro-gun spokesman, in contrast to the ridiculously false assertion by the anti-gun spokesman that for every case where a Good Guy With A Gun stops a life-threatening crime, there are many more when they shoot an innocent victim by mistake. Such a statement begs the question, “If your cause is righteous, why do you have to blatantly lie?”
We are told that the armed hero is grieving because he could not stop the murderer in time to save all the victims. As details of the investigation emerge, it is quite likely that we’ll discover the totality of the circumstances didn’t allow him to stop the murderer sooner. His legacy will be the many lives he saved.
Here’s a clip from News Nation, which appears to have tried to position itself between CNN and Fox News as being non-political. I’ve been a bit skeptical about that, but they took a big step toward living up to their billing when they offered this point/counterpoint on the issue:
Or watch video here.

It drives me crazy comparing the United States to the UK or Japan where the average citizen is not able to get a firearm legally because of the laws that are in place. Last year I was in Vancouver Canada and I was talking with a man and the man brought up the issue of guns. He was telling me that in reality Canada has Per Capita more firearms than the United States does. He said that the difference is that in Canada they are mostly hunting weapons shotguns and rifles. I also met a woman on the cruise we were on that was a retired RCMP Officer and she said that they are only allowed to carry a side arm on duty, which is a very strange situation. Since even Anti gun New York City an officer is supposed to be armed pretty much at all times since they are really never off duty.
Kudos to News Nation.
A lot to unpack in that video, but if we stay on the topic of preventing or stopping school shootings, the message is clear. I heartily agree with Ed Monk’s assertion that limiting the carnage of a psychopath is a matter of math and time. The sooner an attack is stopped, the fewer casualties there will be. Armed citizens in schools is a strong defense, and a stronger deterrent, against school shootings. If an attacker knows his attempt will not succeed, he will not likely try. If he does, he will be stopped long before law enforcement arrives.
A deeper issue is how to handle criminals and psychopaths to begin with. Incarceration and commitment hospitalizations. People need to report, and authorities respond to, dangerous people. A felon with a long history of violence is a public safety threat if not incarcerated, perhaps permanently. Judges need to subordinate their “feelings” to the letter and spirit of the law. Communities need to assert that security trumps political rhetoric.
Suicide by cop is a thing. Suicide by the kindergarten teacher, not so much.
Why do news reports reference “gun violence” but never “sword violence” or “lead pipe violence”?
I understand the armed father, to his credit, is struggling both with not being able to save more lives, AND with having had to end the life of another kid to stop the carnage. Nobody is saying he made the wrong call (well… almost nobody — keep reading), but it’s still tragic, and he has to make peace with it.
Meanwhile, the ultra-liberal Governor of Oregon, Tina Kotek, can’t bring herself to mention the armed father — let alone call him a hero — or even answer a soft-ball question over whether an on-site school resource officer (SRO) might have been able to respond more quickly and save more lives. And forget ever entertaining the possibility of allowing willing and able school staff members to get training and carry; that’s a non-starter.
(Note: The Deschutes County school district, which includes Bend, has SROs, but the State of Oregon has greatly reduced funding for the program, so each SRO rotates among a few schools and he wasn’t at Silver Rail Elementary that day. If the 16-year-old perpetrator had done his research — as many mass killers do, even the mentally-ill ones — he probably knew the SRO would be elsewhere, or at least that the odds would be in his favor.)
An armed and ready SRO can only be at one place at one time. Even at the crime scene when an attack unfolds, he/she is still Target #1. Teachers in street clothes are everywhere, and likely random targets during an attack anyway. It is reasonable and prudent to arm and train as many teachers and staff as possible. Many ‘camouflaged’ defenders on scene can overwhelm a psychopath better than one uniformed officer. An armed civilian has never killed an innocent bystander. Cops with imperfect information have.
“Teachers should not be expected to be warriors.” On a battlefield, everyone is either a combatant or a casualty. Given the choice, most would rather be the former than the latter.
Fort Hood, Uvalde, Parkland: What did they all have in common? Sure, armed guards (well, sorta … keep reading). What ELSE did they have in common? Armed guards that couldn’t or wouldn’t enter the building and stop the carnage.
Fun fact: Army bases on U.S. soil usually DISARM most of the soldiers serving on base. In essence, unless you’re assigned to armed patrol or an MP, you are disarmed by policy, your service guns are locked in the armory, and you are forbidden from carrying a personal gun. Because THAT is how much the cabinet secretaries trust the service-men and -women trained to defend the country.
KUDOS on the reporter/moderator on pointing out that a Good Guy with a Gun who doesn’t act, solves nothing. The cops in Uvalde and Parkland hid outside and didn’t go in, and the Fort Hood shooter attacked a building well-inside the base while the armed guards were on patrol on the perimeter (read: bases are large, and it took several minutes for them to arrive at the actual shooting location).
Equating the Bend shooting with any of these is disingenuous, at best; the facts of each do not support an apples-to-apples comparison. And the other talking points the anti-gun guy spouted — comparison to the U.K., “45,000 gun deaths,” etc., some of them on repeat — are also disingenuous if not outright dishonest, and KUDOS on the reporter/moderator again for calling them out.
Having had some extra time to think about this, this statement — “Equating the Bend shooting with any of these is disingenuous, at best; the facts of each do not support an apples-to-apples comparison.” — while still disingenuous, actually entirely disproves the anti-gunner’s statements.
13 people were murdered at Fort Hood in 2009 (the first of two Fort Hood mass-murders, I would add; there was another in 2014 which killed four [including the shooter] and injured 19). Uvalde, 21. Parkland, 17. All with armed first responders who arrived relatively quickly.
Silver Rail had four — less than a third of even the least-tragic of the three comparisons (not counting the 2nd Fort Hood attack) — because the school did NOT have to wait on professional “first responders.” Someone else was available and showed up to help almost immediately.
And I reiterate: An armed first responder — professional or not — who doesn’t enter the building and engage the attacker, may as well not be there at all. Uvalde and Parkland both demonstrate that. Silver Rail in Bend and In-n-Out in Idaho are shining examples of armed private citizens engaging the criminal and stopping (or at least pausing) the carnage and saving lives.
Does this mean we should “arm teachers”? No, not the way anti-gunners describe — requiring all teachers to carry whether they want to or not — not if they’re not willing to take that responsibility (and many aren’t … which is okay). But I do think we could and should, at the very least, remove the roadblocks for teachers who are willing and able to be armed and respond until police arrive.
I trust the MSM about as far as I can spit.
The guy on the left has sone issues. HE thinks the problem is that young children have access to guns. “““My Dad went to a rural school in Nevada. All the boys, kindergarten and up, had their own rifles, and they came to school with them. They’d have contests at lunch and recess. Rifes were leaned up against the back wall in the schoolroom. The only people any of those students ever shot were the Japs some of them chased out, starting in the Philippines and all the way to Okinawa.
He says doors will help. What about that nutjob trans girl who went and shot up her grade school? She just shot out the door and walked in. Or how bout Columbine? The school resource officer wat in his top flkoor office, looking out the wijndow to the parking lot, and observed the killer park his car in the lot (the court order banning him from that school property did a whole lot, didn’t it ?), get out carrying a Cabelas rifle case, obviously heavy with all those prepped ten round mags, and make his way toward the school, and did
He could have locked down the building, had the controls at his desk.
Uvalde.. someone left the back door of the school building unlocked… the perp just walked up, turned the doorknob, and entered. Almost as if it was part of the plot….. and NONE of the security did anything.
Bend? He just opened a door and walked in, located his first victims and got busy. Until our hero wqalked in after him and took care of business.
Had even ONE school security guy been armed, I believe the tooll would have been zero. And perp disarmed and hog tied, waiting for the paddy wagon.
Funny we have armed security in our banks, where money itself is even rare, bu t re fuse to arm the4 most valuable resource we have….. our children, as they are trapped all the live long day inside those wretched school buildings.
Zero casualties, although possible, is unrealistic. The first victim is usually in the first few seconds and even the best trained defenders have a moment of ‘freeze’, even if very short, responding to an unexpected event in an unlikely place. If a defender can get shots on target quickly, the victim count can be in the low single digits assuming a defender is close to the attacker, as the Silver Rail incident taught us.
The gunman in Bend shot out the glass in the doors and crawled through. Installing relatively cheap security film may have delayed him and allowed the armed citizen to engage him outside.
Given that most killings in mass shootings occur in the first 3 minutes, it is clear that having an armed good guy inside the facility and better still at multiple locations within the facility is one of the very best answers. Therefore, I strongly support allowing volunteer, trained armed teachers to carry concealed inside classrooms. The teachers ought to have some option beyond offering themselves as meat-shields for their students. Teachers who are afraid of guns or don’t want the responsibility or who lack the aptitude to manage the required skills ought not be armed.
Also, since “gun free zones” are the chosen location for over 90% of all mass shootings, most gun-free zones should be eliminated. Especially, CCW Permit Holders should be allowed to enter schools at all grades with concealed firearms. CCW holders have a lower rate of criminal conviction than even police officers according to some studies.
Any official Gun-Free Zone should be required to have limited access with each entrance staffed by at least two armed guards and metal detectors. Otherwise, it is ineffective in barring the truly evil-intentioned aggressor.
Canada actually has nearly 4 times the per capita suicide rate as the USA. The difference is that Canadians do it with drugs instead of with guns most of the time, many of those drugs prescribed by physicians under Canada’s Medical Assistance In Dying (MAID) act.
Finally, Second Amendment related rights ought not end at the state border: We need to implement national reciprocity of CCW recognition, just as we do with driver’s licenses.
That just moves the massacres to the line by the metal detector. There was an incident like that at LAX a few years back. As for the two guards, there were two police officers present at Beslan. One was what we would call and SRO, the other was a parent. Both were in uniform and died in the first 30 seconds.
I’ve not seen or heard anyone (esp anti-s) point out that the teacher wounded in the classroom engaged the shooter and was shot, and it then took an armed defender to STOP the attack. The point being that armed defenders being MUCH more capable of squelching a situation with less risk to him/herself.
I think the teacher actually said in an interview with NPR that she did NOT “throw her phone” or try to attack the shooter, and was shot nearly severing one hand almost immediately.
Unarmed defenses DO happen, but they are much more difficult to succeed.
Greg Ellifritz posted a study about potential spree shootings that were interdicted before the event, and points out this SUCCESS area needs more attention and study.
https:// k12ssdb.org/averted-school-shootings?
He also wrote his own article on this topic a while back…
https:// http://www.activeresponsetraining.net/reflections-on-failure
wow she was GOOD!
I still want to know he just walked in. Even if he shot the door, say what??????
To be fair, there was another hero during the Bend school mass shooting: the female employee who tossed her phone at the looney tunes teen shooter and tackled him. That action gave the brave male “Good Samaritan” enough time to put an end to the rampage and prevent more deaths.
No one seems to be weeping about the dead mass shooter or his stupid mother who provided him with the firearm. She might be prosecuted, convicted, and spend a long time in the gray bar hotel.
When I was in high school in the sixties, my friends and I would bring our shotguns to school, and then go duck hunting after school. Of course all guns stayed in your car/truck until the hunt. My high school has never had a school shooting then or before/since. Times sure have changed.
“If your cause is righteous, why do you have to blatantly lie?”
The answer is that the anti-gun lefties believe that the ends justify the means. They know their agenda will never be accepted by anyone if they use truth. The lefties want the power and control and don’t care how they obtain it. So to them, lying is acceptable, as well as any other means of deceit. They are not concerned with anybody’s welfare – only their power and control.
https://boriquagato.substack.com/p/sunday-memepool-8e4
It’s obvious to the casual observer that Richard has a real bias towards the Armed American Citizen, to the point(s) of exaggerating the number of CRIMINAL HOMICIDES and the number of innocent bystanders shot and/or killed by lawfully armed citizens. The actual rate of such “friendly fire” shootings is MUCH LESS for armed citizens than it is for law enforcement officers.
It seems that Richard strives to live up the shorter, colloquial version of his name.
The moderator did a great job of calling out the distorted stats cited by the “anti”. BTW, those who favor abolishing firearms make the assumption that if a firearm isn’t available, the crime won’t happen. OK, the death won’t be cause by a firearm, but clubs, knives and other methods-including rocks-worked before guns.
A long time ago while channel surfing, I ran across a UK presentation by some folks who researched how various pre-gun weapons were actually used. NOT how it’s generally depicted in movies/TV. ‘Twas shocking. As was some personal familiarization with edged weapons from folks schooled to use them. In this case, ignorance may produce not bliss, but a woefully inadequate grasp of reality. The real world isn’t Nerf world. For those of us who are old, and don’t have the strength and stamina we usta, guns can a great equalized.
I’m not sure how much influence cabinet secretaries have on policies on military bases. Individual commanders and the heads of each service have much more. However, outside threat to the nation wartime, those heads aren’t like the ones we had during actual combat.
Local (elected) school boards and officials can, if properly pressured, act effectively. However, sometimes that requires a realistic threat of legal action to produce change. We had an incident where a student attacked at teacher (picked the wrong teacher, she was a retired Marine) and got his clocked cleaned. She was forced to apologize to the student. A couple of other incidents-and the prospect of legal action- resulted the the board “revising policies”.
So a victim had to apologize to a perpetrator/criminal. How European!
There was no armed guard at Ft. Hood, an MP had to respond by riding his bicycle to the scene. In Uvalde the “armed guards” failed to engage the killer. Parkland was in the process of setting up a School Marshal program to provide for armed faculty, but it wasn’t in place yet.
The real difference between the killings he cited was the number of deaths. In the three cases he cited there were 13, 21, and 17. In the school there were 4, because someone was on the scene and armed. In Oregon the killer shot six people in 30 seconds. Had the school had to wait three minutes for the police (and that’s a very quick response) there could have been six times that.
Everyone was well-behaved during that debate. The anti-gunner was wrong, but at least his arguments had the appearance of being reasonable. No one got overly-emotional. Katie Pavlich did a fantastic job.
As we learned from Massad, Israel solved the school shooter problem in 1974 after the Ma’alot Massacre.
In the 1970s I remember reading MAD magazine. They had a section called “Scenes We’d Like to See.” I’d like to see a killer break into a prison and shoot the criminals on Death Row. Now cue, “All I Have to Do is Dream” by The Everly Brothers.